Tube Diameter and Mechanical Limit of Elevation Travel
US Optics 3.2-17x44mm SN-3 with 35mm tube has approx 18 mils total elevation in two turns, ninety 0.1-mil clicks per revolution. Rifle is an AI-AWP.
The erector's movement within the scope body is limited by the side of the main tube diameter of the scope. Thus the larger the scope tube diameter, the more elevation travel will be mechanically possible. (It is also possible that the elevation knob mechanism itself limits travel before the mechanical limit of the erector. This is most common in "one turn" scopes like the Leupold M3.)
Scope tube diameters include: 1" (25.4mm), 30mm, 34mm (Schmidt & Bender), 35mm (US Optics), and 40mm. The advantages of the larger tube diameters are more elevation travel available and a stronger scope. The disadvantage of larger tube diameters is that the selection of scope rings is few, however, there are several high-quality ring sets available for 34 and 35mm tubes.
Just like the "click" sizes, the spacing of the hash marks for reticle holdover in part determine the smallest engage-able target size. For example, if a reticle has 1 MIL demarcations (ie, in a mildot reticle) and you need to shoot a 10" square target at 600 yards, you need to hold approximately 3.4 mils high, so you'd put the target approx 40% of the way from the 3rd to the 4th mark. If the target is small, there is no precise sight picture-- you're holding "in space" again.
A more sophisticated reticle designed specifically for reticle-based holdover (and windage) is the Horus. The Horus H25 reticle is mil-based, with small tick marks every 0.2mil. A 308 shooter with the H25 reticle can shoot to 1000 yards using the reticle only.
For example, at the TACPRO 2005 sniper match, there was a stage in which 5 targets had to be ranged and engaged with one shot each under a strict time limit. I ranged the targets with my laser and wrote their distances on my note-pad. As I moved from target to target, I only needed to look up the drop for that distance and use hold-over in the Horus H25 reticle. I didn't have to fiddle with any knobs. This demonstrates the speed advantage of reticle-based holdover. A shooter should try to memorize his drop values, and it also helps if he can remember the current target distances or have a spotter to communicate them.
Engaging multiple targets with the Horus reticle at TACPRO 2005. Photo by Frankie Icenogle used with permission.
Hybrid Knob & ReticleThe last method for elevation specification is a hybrid, where the shooter might dial to an intermediate zero like 500 yards from his primary 100 yard zero, and then use reticle-based hold-under and hold-over for targets closer and further than the intermediate zero distance.
Reticle and hybrid holdover has the advantage of being much faster than dialing elevation changes between shots at targets of different range. The downside is that sight picture precision is reduced because of the larger granularity of reticle features vs. typical knob click values.
Again at the 2005 TACPRO sniper match, on a stage where I knew the distances beforehand (325, 375, 500), I dialed to 375, and noted the hold-under for 325 (0.4mil), and the holdover (1.1mil). While shooting the stage, I merely used the appropriate hold-under/over points in the reticle.
First Focal Plane vs Second Focal PlaneIn variable power scopes, a first-focal plane (FFP) reticle configuration means that the angular measure of the reticle features stays constant. No matter what magnification it is set at, 1 MOA will be 1 MOA and 1 MIL will demarcate 1 MIL.
The FFP comes into play because with a wide range variable scope (my SN3 is 3.2-17x), dialing down the power will widen the field of view. Target to target transition times are drastically improved by widening the field of view. The ability to locate targets is enhanced by a wider field of view. To use reticle based holdover without the need to adjust to a specific magnification setting, the scope must have a FFP reticle.
Exit pupil size numbers increase as the scope magnification is dialed down. That's the math behind the observation that a scope at a lower power will produce a brighter image than the same scope dialed up in power. During the day it doesn't make a difference. During the night, it makes a big difference in target ID and sight picture. For an illuminated reticle to be useful, its features need to demarcate the same at whatever magnification is needed for low light.
A FFP reticle setup allows reticle-based and hybrid reticle/click holdover to be used at any magnification setting.
There are some disadvantages to a FFP reticle in certain situations. As the magnification is increased, the width of the lines which comprise the reticle increase in apparent size and will obscure more of the target than the fine lines in a SFP reticle. Conversely, when the magnification is set near the bottom, for example at 4x on a 3.2-17x optic, the reticle lines "shrink" in size along with the target image and may become difficult or impossible to see in some lighting conditions due to their very fine width.